Sunday Forward — Italian American · Week 4
Panna Cotta with Balsamic Glazed Strawberries
Orange-scented set cream · balsamic-glazed strawberries · served in Le Creuset cocottes
Dessert Make-Ahead Elegant Gluten-Free 4 Servings
Orange crema panna cotta with balsamic macerated strawberries in Le Creuset cocottes
4
Servings
20 min
Active
2+ hrs
Chill Time
Easy
Difficulty
The Crema
🧪
Set
Unflavored Knox Gelatin
Bloomed in the orange juice before being whisked into the warm cream — it may look spongy at first, it will melt
1 Tbsp
🍊
Flavor
Large Orange — Zest and Juice
Zest goes into the cream; juice (~½ cup) is used to bloom the gelatin. Use a good, fragrant orange — it’s the main flavor of the crema.
1 large
🧈
Body
Heavy Cream
Full-fat; heated gently with the milk, sugar, and zest. Do not boil.
1 cup
🥛
Lighten
Whole Milk
Lightens the crema slightly from a pure cream panna cotta; keeps the texture silky without being too rich
½ cup
🛢
Sweet
Granulated Sugar — for crema
Stirred into the cream while heating
⅓ cup
Balsamic Strawberries
🍓
Star
Strawberries, sliced
Macerated in sugar and balsamic glaze while the crema chills — they release their juice and the glaze makes a rich, glossy coulis around them
2 cups
🛢
Macerate
Granulated Sugar — for strawberries
Tossed with the sliced strawberries to draw out their juice
3 Tbsp
🍶
Glaze
Balsamic Glaze
See the bruschetta card for Lorianne’s homemade version (Lucini balsamic + honey, simmered until thick) or use a good store-bought reduction
2 Tbsp
Garnish (Optional)
🌿
Finish
Fresh Mint Sprigs or Julienned Orange Zest
Either or both; the orange zest echoes the flavor in the crema and looks beautiful against the red strawberries
as desired
Method
0 of 3 steps complete — click a step to check it off
1Crema
Make and Set the Crema
Sprinkle the gelatin over the orange juice in a small bowl and let it bloom. Meanwhile, combine the cream, milk, ⅓ cup sugar, and orange zest in a small saucepan. Heat gently over medium-low — do not let it boil — for about 5 minutes of steady heat. Remove from the stove and whisk in the bloomed gelatin. It may look spongy at first; keep whisking and it will melt into the warm cream. Holding a fine-mesh sieve over each serving dish or mold, ladle about ½ cup of crema into each of four dishes. Cover tightly with plastic wrap and refrigerate until set, at least 2 hours (overnight is ideal).
2Berries
Macerate the Strawberries
While the crema chills, slice the strawberries and toss gently with the remaining 3 Tbsp sugar and 2 Tbsp balsamic glaze. Cover and refrigerate. As they sit, the sugar and balsamic draw out the strawberry juice, creating a glossy, deeply flavored coulis right in the bowl. At least 30 minutes; an hour or more is better.
3Serve
Uncover and Top with Strawberries
Uncover the crema dishes and spoon a quarter of the macerated strawberries and their juices over each serving. Garnish with fresh mint sprigs or a few strands of julienned orange zest if desired. Serve immediately — or keep covered in the fridge until ready, and top with strawberries at the last moment.
🌡
Do Not Boil the Cream

A boil will change the texture of the finished crema and can interfere with the gelatin’s setting power. Steady medium-low heat for 5 minutes is all it needs — you’re dissolving the sugar and infusing the zest, not cooking the cream.

Give the Strawberries Time

30 minutes of macerating is the floor, not the goal. An hour or more lets the sugar and balsamic really pull the juice out of the strawberries, creating that glossy, pooled coulis you want around each serving. They can macerate in the fridge all day if you make them ahead.

🥄
Sieve Each Pour for a Silky Finish

Holding the sieve over each dish catches any bits of zest or undissolved gelatin before they can mar the smooth surface of the set crema. It takes about 10 extra seconds per dish and makes a visible difference in the finished texture.

🍶
Balsamic Glaze — See the Bruschetta Card

The glaze used here is the same one from the Week 4 bruschetta card: ½ cup Lucini balsamic simmered with 1–1½ Tbsp honey until thick and syrupy. Store-bought thick balsamic reduction works perfectly too.

Two Le Creuset cocottes with panna cotta and balsamic strawberries being spooned in
Spooning in the macerated strawberries
Single Le Creuset cocotte with panna cotta and balsamic strawberries
Ready to serve