Sunday Forward — Italian American · Week 4
Pesto Chicken Insalata Caprese
Pan-roasted chicken · Lorianne’s almond pesto · ciliegine · cherry tomatoes · pan juices
30 Minutes Weeknight Date Night Gluten-Free Uses Pesto
Pesto chicken insalata caprese on a white oval platter — golden pan-roasted chicken slices alongside ciliegine and cherry tomatoes tossed in almond pesto
2
Servings
15 min
Active
25 min
Total
Easy
Difficulty
👫
Sized for Two

With the girls and the boyfriend in and out so much this summer, Week 4 became a just-us menu — this dish, the piccata, the branzino, and the pesto shrimp pasta are all portioned for two. Doubling for company? The chicken and ciliegine scale up easily.

The Chicken
🍗
Star
Chicken Breasts
Same buy as the piccata: bone-in, skin-on is cheaper — debone and leave the skin on for extra flavor, or bone and skin them fully before pounding. Boneless-skinless works too if butchering isn’t your thing. Pounded to even thickness — even thickness means an even cook, no dry edges.
2 breasts
🧈
Sear
Unsalted Butter
Combined with olive oil for the pan-roast — butter for flavor and color, oil to raise the smoke point
1 Tbsp
🫒
Sear
Olive Oil
Combined with the butter for pan-roasting
2 Tbsp
🧂
Season
Salt & Black Pepper
Season before the chicken goes in the pan
to taste
Insalata Caprese
🌿
Sauce
Lorianne’s Almond Pesto
The second cup from the pesto card — used here as the dressing for the caprese. If coming from the fridge, let it come to room temp while the chicken cooks.
¾ cup
🍅
Sweet
Cherry Tomatoes
Halved or left whole; they toss into the pesto and pick up all the basil and almond flavor. A pint is plenty for two.
1 pint
🧀
Cheese
Ciliegine (Fresh Mozzarella Balls)
The cutest little balls — cherry-tomato-sized, pillowy, and deeply savory. An 8 oz Whole Foods container includes the brine; strain well before adding so the pesto coats the cheese rather than getting watered down. Use the full container.
1 container (~8 oz), drained
🍋
Finish
Lemon
A squeeze over the finished plate — never hurts, always brightens
1, for squeezing
Method
0 of 4 steps complete — click a step to check it off
1Roast
Pound and Pan-Roast the Chicken
Pound the chicken breasts to an even thickness. Season with salt and pepper. Heat the butter and olive oil together in a skillet over medium-high until the butter foam subsides. Add the chicken and pan-roast 6–7 minutes per side without moving it — you want a proper golden crust. The target internal temperature is 165°F.
2Caprese
Toss the Insalata While the Chicken Cooks
Combine the pesto, cherry tomatoes, and ciliegine in a shallow bowl. Toss gently to coat everything in the pesto. The mozzarella will pick up a beautiful green from the basil oil. Set aside — it can sit at room temperature while the chicken finishes. If pesto came from the fridge, this is also when it warms up.
3Rest + Slice
Rest, Slice, and Arrange
When the chicken hits 165°F, move it to a cutting board and let it rest 3–5 minutes. Slice on a slight bias and arrange the slices on a plate or shallow bowl, fanning them slightly so the golden crust and juicy interior both show.
4Finish
Add Pan Juices, Spoon Caprese, Squeeze Lemon
Stir the pan juices from the skillet into the caprese mixture — they carry all the butter, olive oil, and fond from the sear and make the salad richer and more savory. Spoon the caprese alongside the sliced chicken. Finish with a squeeze of fresh lemon over the whole plate.
🍳
Don’t Skip the Pan Juices

The pan juices stirred into the caprese are what separates this from a plain pesto salad. The butter-and-chicken fond that collected in the pan while searing transforms the pesto mixture into something richer and more unified. Deglaze with a splash of water if the pan looks dry.

🌿
This Is the Second Cup of Pesto

This recipe and the Pesto Shrimp & Spinach Pasta each draw from the same pesto batch — make the pesto first, then split it. This dish uses ¾ cup — taste as you toss the caprese and adjust to your preference.

🍋
The Lemon at the End

A squeeze of fresh lemon over the finished plate is described as “never hurts” — it does more than that. The acid cuts through the richness of the pesto and butter, wakes up the tomatoes, and ties the whole plate together. Don’t skip it.

Photos
Pesto chicken caprese on a dark plate — sliced chicken with crispy skin fanned alongside the pesto caprese
Colin’s pan-roast on the dark plate